Wednesday, April 23, 2008
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time
The main speaker at the graduation was John Ellice-Flint, distinguished alumnus, ex-CEO of Santos, and 2020 summiteer. He talked about climate change. He did it ably enough that he never had me offside. I shall give a very rough paraphrase of his speech, as it is not the done thing to take notes, and my memory is not what it once was.
He didn’t waste any time emoting about environmental catastrophe, and stated at the outset that he was going to set to one side the whole debate about the nature and extent of global warming.
He pointed out that the large developing nations were not going to abandon fossil fuels, whatever we did: we would have to accept that fossil fuels were going to be a major part of the world energy mix for some time to come.
He gave an internet factoid about the number of wind turbines China would have to build every day in order to equal the number of coal-fired power plants it was building.
He said the only way we could hope to make an impact on carbon dioxide emissions in the short-term was to throw barrow-loads of money at scientists and engineers- the one outcome of Global Warming hysteria that I have always felt to be an unqualified good.
He said he felt confident that the new government would rise to the challenge of providing these barrow-loads of money, and that in achieving world-class expertise in these areas Australia would soon earn it back many times over.
He talked a bit more about renewables, and a bit more about carbon-capture. I forget exactly what he said. I was waiting for him to mention the ‘N’ word.
But he didn’t!
Not once.
The word ‘nuclear’ did not pass his lips.
He is obviously on top of the whole big picture of greenhouse-gas abatement. He is obviously a clever bloke. He is obviously well-connected.
And it is pretty obvious that the nuclear option is one that is going to be adopted by a lot of our neighbours in our Near North, whether or not an ice age starts tomorrow, because we are going to run out of coal eventually, no matter how clean it is. It seemed obvious to me that the arguments he made with respect to developing expertise in renewables and carbon-capture applied equally well to expertise in nuclear power. And it seems obvious to me that since we are already involved in the nuclear industry as a supplier of uranium, we have not only an economic opportunity but a moral duty to take responsibility for the whole fuel cycle: to provide processed fuel to our customers (to reduce proliferation concerns) and to take back their waste (because it was ours to begin with, because we have ideal political and geological conditions to store it, and again, to reduce proliferation concerns).
But Mr Ellice-Flint didn’t mention nuclear power at all.
I am sure it didn’t just slip his mind.
I am sure he had some perfectly good reasons not to mention it.
But unfortunately, by not mentioning it, he couldn’t help but come across as someone pushing a narrow carbon-capture agenda, rather than an honest broker surveying the challenges of our energy future.
Sunday, March 9, 2008
The Myth of Terra Stasis
You will have to imagine that if you turned around from where you were standing and seeing this, there they would be, looking quite shady and inviting at that hour of the afternoon.

The sign describing the shelters did something that is relatively common in things written about Aboriginal culture for popular consumption but which always irritates me as a pedant.
It said something like: ‘The Wiradjuri people have used shelters like these for 20,000 years.’
This cannot possibly be true.
It is sloppy shorthand for two things that are almost certainly true:
(1) The Wiradjuri people used shelters like these.
(2) Traces of shelters like these have been found dating back to 20,000 years in this area.
It should say: ‘The people of Wiradjuri country have used shelters like these for 20,000 years’.
Here is a worse example, as near as I can remember it, from a newsletter put out by my old university many years ago:
‘The original meaning of these images [in 4000 year old rock art in the Chillagoe region of North Queensland] is unknown because the Aboriginal people of the area were removed to Palm Island and their stories were lost.’
It is a very real tragedy that the stories of these people were lost. But there is no way they had any idea of the ‘original meaning’ of 4000-year-old images. You wouldn’t dream of writing:
‘The original meaning of the Uffington white horse is unknown because the villagers of the area were removed to make way for a motorway and their stories were lost.’
We know that the oral history of England is not trustworthy over thousands of years. We know that peoples have come and gone, and that there is no real memetic link between the people that made the Uffington white horse and the people who happened to live near it in the 20th century.
These are only two examples of the denial of Aboriginal history.
Here is a third, which is not just of interest to pedants, because it means potentially interesting and important science is being ignored.
I was recently at Lake Mungo National Park. The visitor’s centre made no mention at all of the controversial mitochondrial DNA studies that appear to show that the 40,000 year-old ‘Mungo Man’ remains are genetically distinct from all modern humans- something that I had heard about and was keen to know more about.
Instead, there was stuff along the lines of what is quoted in this article:
“Non-indigenous Australians too often have a desperately limited frame of historical reference. The Lake Mungo region provides a record of land and people that we latter day arrivals have failed to incorporate into our own Australian psyche. We have yet to penetrate the depths of time and cultural treasures revealed by those ancestors of indigenous Australians,” [Prof Jim Bowler] says.
If you were excavating 40,000 year-old remains in Spain, you wouldn’t expect them to shed any light on the ‘rights and richness’ of present-day Spaniards. Pretending that the present inhabitants of an area that has experienced dramatic and extensive climatic changes necessarily have memetic or genetic links with the people who lived there 40,000 years ago is not endearing and culturally sensitive.
It is unscientific. It is deeply irritating to pedants. And what is more, it is insultingly patronising.
The Aboriginal population were not part of the scenery, waiting around in the same place doing the same things for thousands of years so that white folks could turn up and history could begin. They had a history that was surely every bit as rich and interesting as the pre-Colombian history of North America. People moved around. Cultures changed. Peoples replaced other peoples. Interesting history happened. We don’t know what it was, and to a large extent we can never know. We have yet to ‘penetrate the depths of time’. But it is an important and interesting part of human history that I would love to know more about.
Things I learned in Canberra
All eukaryotes have mitochondrial DNA.
This DNA codes for things that are useful in mitochondria.
This set of things, however, is different across different species.
Over all species, however, there is not one thing useful in mitochondria that is not coded for in nuclear DNA.
Second, I learned that there is extremely good evidence for transposons acting to transfer a beneficial characteristic from one species to another- specifically, to transform an inert species of fungus into a wheat pathogen. I always thought this sort of thing was a theoretical possibility, but I had never heard any good evidence of it happening in eukaryotes before. Voila, it happens!
Third, I learned that I need to learn a lot more about plants.
Green plants are more complicated then us. They have larger genomes, on average, and have chloroplasts with their own DNA as well as mitochondria with their own DNA. They make an awful lot of things that we have to get by eating other things, so they have more complicated metabolic pathways. Our sense of how natural selection works is also skewed by us usually thinking of animals rather than plants, despite all that rigmarole with peas back in Mendel’s time: one animal individual crosses with one other individual to make some offspring. But consider your typical tree, covered with gazillions of flowers: it is more like one individual crossing with the whole population within ever so many kilometres to make some offspring. Actually, don’t a lot of animals in the ocean do the same sort of thing?
I learned specifically that I need to learn more about the immune system of plants. It seems plants have no acquired immune system. Each plant cell is autonomous, and just has the genetic potential for immunity that it started out with. A plant can’t acquire antibodies to something new and strange the way we can. (Memo to self: how do we actually do this, again? I need also to revise what I sort of kind of once knew about the immune system of us.) You would think, without any acquired resistance, plants would need a rapid turnover of generations to have any chance of adapting to pathogens. Sure, a lot of plants do seem to have a rapid turnover of generations. Yet, we have these things called trees that live for hundreds or thousands of years. How do they do it? They are likely to be facing a completely different pathogenic environment at the end of their lives than at the beginning. They are supposed to have no more resistance than what they were genetically programmed with.
Action: Learn about the molecular biology and evolutionary biology of plants. It is interesting.
I ought to point out that Marco's thoughts about evolution were rattling about in my head while I was learning these things.
Sunday, February 10, 2008
A Talk to some National Youth Science Forum Students, 8/2/08


An ‘experiment’ is just a small, controlled bit of ‘experience’. That’s all.


And in between 2nd year and 3rd year, I happened to read something about the discovery of the structure of DNA- I think it was this famous book- and I thought, aha! I will do biochemistry. Biochemistry really is the science of the 21st century. It is where the big discoveries are being made that will cure cancer and give us potatoes that grow plastic instead of starch and let us genetically modify ourselves so we look like Klingons.

What he meant was, once we understand what is going on with the physics, the basic ground rules of the universe, and once we have nutted out precisely what is happening with the sort of life we have on our planet that is all based on a very, very, very, small subset of the possible chemical reactions, we can go off and create things that are as complicated as life, but that use different chemistry. The buzzword ‘nanotechnology’ is a first little prefiguring of that 25thcentury that Jean Marie Lehn is dreaming about.

But since I grew up in a provincial city, under balmy tropical skies, living in Sydney for me was too much like living in a box full of starving weasels, and I couldn’t possibly see myself living the rest of my life in *that* sort of place. [Note 8]
Thursday, January 31, 2008
Four Things I Never Heard
* 70% of NSW canola is herbicide-resistant strains generated by conventional breeding.
These are mostly resistant to triazine herbicides, which build up in the environment. The genetically-modified versions available are resistant to glufosinate ammonium or glyphosate, herbicides which degrade rapidly and do not build up in the environment. So GM canola is unlikely to lead to increased herbicide use and there is a clear environmental benefit in introducing them in terms of the herbicides used.
* Our non-GM bulk canola gets the same price in world markets as Canadian GM canola.
So there is no question of us throwing away a 'premium' for a non-GM product. Our yields are just a lot lower because the triazine-resistant varieties are not as high-yielding.
* No 'organic' canola is grown in New South Wales.
So there is no chance of us jeopardising a small boutique industry which is getting a premium price for its product.
* EU and Japanese regulations on the labelling of non-GM foods allow up to 0.9% GM material (EU) and 5%(!) GM material (Japan).
This is far more than documented cases of accidental contamination of non-GM fields from the GM field across the fence, so if a premium non-GM market *did* develop, the fact that GM canola was being grown in the same part of the country would do nothing to stop farmers from participating in it.
This goes to show that there are great benefits to be gained in travelling to other institutions and attending seminars one wouldn't normally go to. I have known for years that the health and environmental arguments against GM foods were bogus, and is interesting to find that the economic ones are (at least in this case) bogus as well.
Wednesday, December 5, 2007
Google Shock
Monday, November 5, 2007
Good on him!
Sunday, November 4, 2007
My run of luck ends
I was 4/4 for letters to major newspapers over the last couple of years. (Finding these is left as a Googling exercise for the reader). This time I have had a go at Dr Karl, and my letter has passed into limbo.
In this article in the Sydney Morning Herald on Friday, Dr Karl is quoted as claiming that
Back in May we were told that Australians produce ‘more than five’ tonnes of carbon per capita per annum. That is, more than 18 tonnes of carbon dioxide per capita per annum.
This other site indicates that total Australian greenhouse gas emissions are of the order of 600 million tonnes of carbon dioxide per annum.
Thus, we can guess at 20-30 tonnes of carbon dioxide per capita per annum in
This gives 80-120 million tonnes of carbon dioxide per annum in
This is 1.8-2.7 trillion moles of carbon dioxide.
Which is 40-60 trillion (1012) litres of carbon dioxide at atmospheric pressure.
Which is admittedly a lot.
There are a trillion litres in a cubic kilometre.
So, we have 40-60 cubic kilometres of uncompressed carbon dioxide per annum. That is more like one a week, not one a day.
Week, day, whatever. Near enough is good enough, as my uncle who builds space probes for NASA says.
The article claims that
One mole of carbon dioxide at atmospheric pressure will occupy 22.4 litres. By pV= nRT, if we put it under a pressure of 100 atmospheres, it will occupy near enough to 1% of that. I don’t know what sort of pressure is appropriate for the zeroth-order ‘pumping it into empty oil and gas reservoirs’ sort of carbon capture technology. But I do know that the grail of this sort of thing is converting carbon dioxide into a solid.
One mole of carbon dioxide converted into, say, calcium carbonate, will occupy 37 cubic centimetres.
So, rather than ‘one cubic kilometre per day’ we have 0.10-0.15 cubic kilometres per day, which could be theoretically converted into 0.0002-0.0003 cubic kilometres of calcium carbonate per day. That would be about 20 times as much as the solid waste currently produced by
Here is how I ended my letter:
‘The fact that many different people are working on many different strategies to solve a problem should be a source of optimism and joy. That a group called the Climate Change Coalition would malign the motives of researchers pursuing carbon sequestration technologies is depressing, to say the least.’
Tuesday, October 30, 2007
O tempora! O mores!
Here are two more things I don't understand, which I will have a proper stab at real soon now:
(1) What is it with quantum teleportation? My gut feeling is that ‘teleportation’ is an illusion arising from us looking at things the wrong way.
(2) Ditto for the ‘collapse’ of a wavefunction.
What happens to these concepts in the De Broglie pilot-wave model? This is a model which can explain the mysterious double-slit experiments- where electrons (and neutrons, and helium nuclei) seem to interfere with each other as if they were waves *even if only one is sent through at a time* - in terms of each particle really being a particle but being guided by a 'pilot wave'. I find this much more satisfactory than wave/particle duality- which of course has no bearing on whether it is true or not.
De Broglie's abandoned this theory, but other people have been mucking about with it and optimising it from time to time. But, as a mere chemist, I don't really understand what they are saying.
“One singular deception of this sort ... is to mistake the sensation produced
by our own unclearness of thought for a character of the object we are
thinking. Instead of perceiving that the obscurity is purely subjective, we
fancy that we contemplate a quality of the object which is essentially
mysterious; and if our conception be afterward presented to us in a clear
form we do not recognise it as the same, owing to the absence of the feeling
of unintelligibility.”
- Charles Sanders Peirce, ‘How to Make Our Ideas Clear’
Friday, August 3, 2007
Sunday, July 22, 2007
Listening to the Sky
Curiously, I have come away with rather more scepticism about the Big Bang model than I had hitherto. I still think that the weight of the evidence is vastly in its favour. Declaring my biases, I still find it vastly more congenial to my worldview. However, I would no longer put it in the ‘that’s settled, then’ basket with continental drift and the evolution of all terrestrial life from a common ancestor.
(1) Briefly, the basic big bang model predicts background radiation in the universe that fits the blackbody radiation curve and is homogeneous with the same intensity in all directions. The steady-state model doesn’t. We have found background radiation which beautifully, definitely, fits the blackbody radiation curve. However, it is not homogeneous. Is it easier to tweak the big bang theory so that the radiation isn’t homogeneous, or the steady-state theory so that the background is thermal? Probably the former. And there are a lot of other problems with the steady state theory. Still, I can’t help wondering- if for purely historical reasons most theorists had stayed in the steady-state paradigm and devoted their lives to tweaking it, and only a few crackpots had kept beavering away at the big-bang model, would we have an elegant steady-state model today that fit all the data perfectly? Maybe we wouldn’t, but maybe we would. I just am not as sure as I was before that the universe is busily beating us over the head with the right answer.
(2) This is not an objection to the theory at all, but it is something I hadn’t known before, and it would certainly be something that would be shouted to the rooftops if a similar situation were to arise today- e.g., if a researcher affiliated with an oil company came up with a theory for climate change that confirmed the expected biases of their employer, even if it fit the data better than the anthropogenic global warming one. The Catholic church is not just perfectly happy with the Big Bang because it is consistent with Catholic ideas: it was a Catholic priest who came up with the theory.
Friday, July 13, 2007
The Clone Wars
I think it would be handy for all sorts of people who because of disease, accident, sexual orientation, or vocation, are unable to pass on their genetic material in the regular way. It has two problems, but these are problems shared by other assissted reproductive technologies:
(1) Wastage of ‘surplus’ embryos. I know nature does this, but I still think we should strive to keep it to a minimum.
(2) Health problems in the offspring. These are well documented but relatively minor for children put together by in vitro fertilisation. With cloning on the other hand, in the mammals we have looked at so far there are all sorts of peculiar and unexplained health problems. It would be criminal to experiment on human reproductive cloning at the moment because of these problems.
But there is no reason we should not keep on experimenting on our near relatives. Primates seem to be tricky things to clone. By all means let us try to clone chimpanzees. Once we can reliably clone perfectly healthy chimpanzees with a minimum of embryo wastage, why not apply the same technology to ourselves? I see no rational reason not to.
I do see therapeutic cloning as intrinsically wrong.
I think deliberately creating human embryos in order to destroy them is going too far. I don’t lose a great deal of sleep over it, because I was lucky enough to hear a talk in February 2006 by Graham Parker who is on the board of the journal ‘Stem Cell Research’ and works at a research hospital in Michigan. I learned the following things:
(1) The more differentiated a stem cell is when you start messing around with it, the more effective it is. This is why we still need to donate blood, and don’t just culture haemotopoetic stem cells. Inner-cell-mass-derived (aka embryonic) stem cells are less differentiated than somatic (aka adult) stem cells and appear much more likely to turn into invasive cancers when you inject them into mice.
(2) Nobody has a clue how stem cells really work clinically. It does not look like they just move in and turn into the sort of cells that are around them. They do other weird things that nobody understands yet.
(3) The chaps who first discovered inner-cell-mass-derived stem cells never claimed they had clinical uses. They still don’t. They are of fundamental importance in understanding developmental biology, which is important fundamental research and will eventually lead to all sorts of innovations- but they won’t involve injecting people with stem cells. 97+% of this fundamental research could (and should) be done with stem cells of the other mammals that we share so much of our DNA with.
This suggests to me that we are not likely ever to have a situation where therapeutic cloning would be done on an industrial scale and would be a big moral quandary for anyone with a serious illness. And if someone says, ‘I want to experiment on human embryonic stem cells’, the correct response is, ‘go do your experiments on chimpanzee embryonic stem cells’. There is no justification for playing with human embryonic stem cells. Maybe, once you have demonstrated that you can reliably and safely repair damaged chimpanzee brains, or whatever, then we can sit down and have a debate on extending the technology to humans.
Thursday, June 14, 2007
Granddad's Biography
I was pleased to discover his philosophy of examinations:
I always felt that an exam should be a learning experience and, at a graduate level, all exams were take-home exams where a student could consult with any book or person. The catch, however, was that the questions had no answers, and the grade was based upon the approach to unanswerable questions. Students have come back later to tell me that this was the greatest experience they had in preparing them for the real world.



