Wednesday, May 24, 2017

So Long and Thanks for All the Fish


I joined the Royal Australian Chemical Institute (RACI) in 1989, as a second year student. I became a full member (MRACI) when I finished my PhD, and a Fellow (FRACI) in 2014. Over the years I’ve carried out a number of roles for the RACI, including Treasurer of the Polymer Division (2002-2009).

I’ve just quit today.

I’ve quit because of this Inclusion and Diversity Policy.



This is an Exclusion policy which could only be conceived and implemented in a perfectly Non-diverse intellectual monoculture.

Equity means that the biological composition of plenary, keynote and invited speakers ought to mirror the biological composition of researchers at an appropriate level in the subject matter of the conference. Sometimes this composition will be greater than 30% female. Sometimes it will be less than 30% female. Having this simplistic numerical benchmark means that in many cases people of equal merit will be excluded on the basis of what sex they are. That is the definition of sexual discrimination.
 
I am all for absolutely busting a gut for equality of opportunity. But taking any step down the road to equality of outcome should be absolutely anathema to the spirit of any scientific society.

This business of quotas is poison. It is cancer. It encourages imposter syndrome in the 'beneficiaries' and reinforces prejudice in those who it excludes. It does absolutely nothing to help a mid-career researcher who would have been a plausible pick as an invited speaker but for the family responsibilities that have held her back, or the systemic sexual discrimination she faced building a career in Faroffistan.

Furthermore, unconscious bias training is nonsense.

10 comments:

Unknown said...

Shades of 1984 and a whole range of despicable governments in history. Do these people not know their science fiction or their history? Even if they could trust the test (and scientists should have checked the test worked themselves first), in what world do they think thought police is a good idea.

Anonymous said...


What proportion of the members of the institute are female?

Chris Fellows said...

I don't know, David. My Google Fu has failed me. I expect a current member could access the member database on their website and let you know.

kristen said...

I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I will keep visiting. Students can get online assignment service from expert writers.

Francis said...

nice

The Land Associates said...

Users can choose to add rental car insurance, additional driver and include flight information if they are picking vehicle up from airport. Travelers who need special equipment like GPS device or a child safety seat can make requests directly with rental cars the UAE.

Unknown said...

So sorry to hear this Chris. From what you have written. It begs the question, was the policy written by scientists with the best interest of the preservation and communication of good science at heart or was it written by a person with a humanities degree pushing for political correctness? Hmm.. I wonder. It begs the question, which is the higher virtue? One is for the cause for our humanity and the environment. In my mind the other for the school playground. It is important that socioeconomic disadvantage has remedy and woman assisted back into science after nurturing families but requiring quotas that handicap the rest of the field is not in the best interest of science or the integrity and self respect of the disadvantaged. Regards, a woman who is a bit over women demanding that equality is the getting the same. It's not.

Pk said...

We offer the best GIF Homework Help services in the market today.

Anonymous said...

Most of the times, kids are often interested in playing with the toys. you can buy several kind of toys from amazon but you can't get unique variety toys from the amazon. It is because kids motorbikes are one of the ride on Vehicles which are more liked by the children, but, you rarely found very few models on world's largest e-commerce. However, you can buy kids electric motorbike from the store which offer very unique and different range of the models to the consumers. They have scooties, sports bikes and also electric motor vehicles with more than 50+ variety of bikes to choose from. Even the price is also very affordable as you can get the ride on bike starting from $49 and highest range being around $129.

If you were looking for a good quality kids ride on motorbike, then you need to buy from the trusted and certified retailer. These retailers direectly source the products from the chinese manufacturers on the "alibaba which is famous for most of the toy imports to the UK. they partner with one of the most trusted manufacturers who are being in the Industry since so many years and have En71 certified quality materials will be used while manufacturing the products. They also provide 1 year warranty for the products and also have best customer support after the sales.

Hence getting the kids motorbikes from such kind of retailers will help to ensure that your child won't get disappointed. Especially, children will easily break anything these days but if you want a product which lasts longer than need to buy from the certified retailers who offer the warranty. The site also offers free delivery to the customers all across the United Kingdom making the ride on vehicles to be most affordable for the parents to gift to their children. Thus if you were looking to buy the ride on children's motorbike then have a look at the store.

--

jane said...

Interesting read, I loved the content I bookmarked the website for regular read CMI Assignment Help is tailor made and pocket friendly to our client.